By Michael Kuttner…
Between now and the end of November there are scheduled to be five electoral contests which will have potential negative or positive implications for Jews and Israel.
Their impact is bound to be important and critical especially at this time when rampant hate and incitement abound and rampaging ignorance is the order of the day.
The first date to watch is 27 October when Israeli citizens resident in the country go to the polls. For the first time in thirty-eight years the coalition has lasted the full term of 4 years which is some sort of a dubious record.
Two other factors need emphasizing.
The Israeli election process is purely manual with strict security and safety protocols thus making it virtually impossible to manipulate and corrupt. It is very simple with voters required to select a small piece of paper with the name and symbol of the party of their choice, put it into an envelope, seal it and drop it into a sealed ballot box. No electronic manipulation, fraud or foul ups are possible as the whole process from voting to counting is closely scrutinized.
Apart from diplomats, shlichim and others on State business there is no overseas or absentee postal voting. Some maintain that this discriminates against those not present in the country on election day. Those Israelis who have made somewhere else their permanent home should not be entitled to vote for a country they no longer intend to reside in.
What are the hot topics of the campaign and what are the possible outcomes?
With 37 parties to choose from, spanning left to right, religious and secular as well as multi ethnic permutations, voters have myriad choices.
In most democracies economic considerations and social problems are major bones of contention with clear differences usually manifest between socialist left and conservative right wings of the political spectrum. Matters of security, defence and military strategies although important tend to play a more minor role.
In Israel, the order of priorities is somewhat different.
Security and the fight against terror as well as protecting the country from external threats tend to take priority. This is understandable when one realizes that ever since the re-establishment of sovereignty in 1948 the country has been under constant and unremitting danger from those who daily proclaim its demise.
In addition, Israel is the only country in the world which has its legitimacy challenged on a daily basis. These factors necessitate political parties to concentrate on policies deemed unimportant in most other nations.
Economic and social challenges are certainly critical but with 37 parties spanning the political spectrum it is not easy to separate them into clearly identifiable categories.
In these elections certain controversial subjects will weigh foremost on voters’ minds.
The refusal to establish an official commission of inquiry into the 7 October Hamas pogrom, investigate its failures and delve into the policies leading up to this disaster is a burning topic.
Ongoing scandals about the mass refusal to enlist young Charedi men into the IDF or community service and the funding of their institutions are hot topics.
Social inequalities and the cost of living also need addressing.
Judicial reform is a hot potato which needs solving.
At the end of the day the election outcome will hinge on how many votes each bloc receives. Will the existing coalition of right wing plus Ultra Orthodox parties manage to garner more votes or will the opposition bloc prevail? The problem for the opposing parties is that there are too many of them. In addition each leader wants to be PM whereas the governing coalition has Netanyahu as the undisputed head.
Will disgust with the current Government manifest itself in them losing votes? If voters believe that it is time for a change who will they choose? How many will turn out on the day and actually cast a ballot? Will a disunited opposition squander a possible opportunity? Will Trump’s endorsement of Bibi help or hinder him? How will the Arab parties perform?
There are so many permutations that it is almost impossible to forecast an outcome. Forget the opinion polls which are notoriously unreliable. Watch out for last minute withdrawals from the contest as it becomes clearer which parties may not pass the 3.25% minimum barrier.
One thing is for sure. Regardless of the result, the world’s Zionist, Israel and Jew haters will not disappear. That scourge will remain and must be dealt with by whoever gains power after 27 October.
On 3 November American citizens will be voting in the mid terms.
Unlike Israel the choice facing eligible voters is restricted to only two parties. For supporters of Jewish sovereignty in Israel, current and subsequent choices look increasingly impossible. Faced with a Democratic Party veering sharply leftwards and embracing policies which would inevitably lead to Israel’s eradication Jews who have voted Democrat all their lives face an impossible dilemma. Do they go like lambs to the slaughter and vote for anti Israel candidates or do they abstain voting altogether?
If, as seems increasingly likely, the isolationist and Jewish conspiracy wings of the Republican Party become more influential, where is a Jewish supporter of Israel supposed to go? Jew and Zionist hate in both parties is on the rise fueled by long latent prejudices and growing ignorance of historical facts and realities.
Galloping assimilation and increasing detachment add to the fraught situation facing American Jewish voters. This has resulted in the rise of “anti Zionist” day schools and communities which foster the myth that Judaism has nothing to do with Israel. Blaming Israeli politicians for rising hate in the USA may resonate with the disaffected. It does not however, given Jewish experiences over the millennia, guarantee immunity from rising homegrown enmity.
In today’s US realities Jews are becoming disenfranchised. As a result of a corruptible system whereby there are only two choices, each one of which may be worse than the other, the prognosis is dire.
Increasing numbers of Jewish families are voting with their feet and by 2028 the choices will be even starker.
In New Zealand elections are scheduled for 7 November.
For the first time a party totally dedicated to Israel’s destruction is officially registered to take part. Although its chances of success are zero this should be of no comfort to the country’s miniscule Jewish population.
If an opposition coalition of Labour, Greens and Maori Party gain power the probability of anti Israel policies becoming enacted will be very high. All three parties already have manifestos which cover a range of punitive action against Israel.
Boycotts, sanctions and the expulsion of the Israeli Embassy are only the tip of the iceberg. If the Greens follow the example of their UK counterparts they will declare “Zionism as racism” and attempt to outlaw all those who support Jewish sovereignty anywhere in the ancient homeland.
New Zealand’s Jewish population is so insignificant that it carries no political clout. Like the situation in the UK and Europe, Australia and increasingly so also in North America, rapidly growing Islamic voters are courted assiduously. As jihadist brainwashing of the media and university students gathers steam the political fallout will inevitably follow.
The situation is not yet beyond redemption but time is running out for Jews down under if the current trend accelerates.
To round off a month of electoral expectations we can look forward to elections in the State of Victoria, Australia on 28 November and in Spain on 29 November.
The Victorian contest is a first test of how the electorate views the Labour Party. It will be interesting to see whether voters cast their protest ballots towards the opposition parties. For Jewish voters who support the Zionist enterprise and have not yet been sucked into progressive anti Israel narratives the result will be an early indication of possible Federal trends to come.
Unfortunately, there are still far too many who prefer either to deny that there is any problem or that it will all blow over at some stage. We have seen this scenario all too often in the past and it does not end well.
On 29 November Spanish voters will go to the polls as a result of an early election caused by the collapse of the current leftist Government. Spain has the dubious distinction together with Ireland of being among the most Israel/Zionist/Jew hating countries in the EU. Given their current trajectory it won’t be long before they join their French counterparts in battling out of control mobs and rioters.
If Spanish voters elect a conservative coalition there could be a reversal of anti Israel policies which in turn might alleviate the rampaging animosity ravaging the country.
I cannot conclude without mentioning a blatant electoral farce which has hardly elicited any response from the international community.
Fake “Palestine” which has been “recognized” by Australia, Canada, UK, France, Ireland and other assorted UN members has not held any elections for over twenty years. Every so often they promise to hold them but as soon as it becomes obvious that Abbas and Fatah might lose they are postponed. After the above countries extended recognition Abbas promised that free and fair elections would follow. All of us who know exactly the track record of the Ramallah based kleptochracy predicted that only fools and useful idiots would fall for that charade again.
Sure enough, just as the designated date loomed, Abbas announced that the elections had been postponed until September 2027.
Naturally someone had to get the blame for this latest move and of course it had to be Israel. This follows a script which has remained unchanged over seven decades. Blame all misfortunes and deceitful deceptions on the Jews. It’s simple because the rest of the world will swallow this hook, line and sinker, as they always have done.
Have you heard any howls of protest from the UN and those countries which rushed to extend statehood? Nary a peep has been forthcoming. At least New Zealand’s Foreign Minister had the good sense to withhold recognition of “Palestine” until certain conditions were met. The others rushed blindly ahead putting their trust in promises which never would be fulfilled.
The next two months are going to be action packed.
Post mortems on the results will be forthcoming in due course.
Michael Kuttner is a Jewish New Zealander who for many years was actively involved with various communal organisations connected to Judaism and Israel. He now lives in Israel.
[This article was originally published on J-Wire and is reproduced here with permission from Michael Kuttner.]
